Neighborhoods are back in the city’s master plan, says Councilman Roberto Treviño

Updated: District 1 Councilman Roberto Treviño said the San Antonio Planning Department is “not going to take another step forward” on the SA Tomorrow Comprehensive Plan without including the neighborhoods as true partners in the process.

In a video interview, Treviño said he met with Planning Director Bridgett White and with her boss, Deputy City Manager Peter Zanoni, to establish a new direction and framework after NOWCastSA published videos and articles disclosing the planning department’s methodic determination to eliminate neighborhood plans in the Comprehensive Plan.

Neighborhood leaders, who formed the Tier One Neighborhood Coalition in 2016 to fight to protect their community plans from the Comprehensive Plan process, celebrated their hard-fought victory. “Councilman Roberto Treviño deserves our thanks in insisting that our voices be heard by the City and that our neighborhoods be protected,” wrote co-founder Cynthia Spielman in an email to the 40 neighborhood groups in the Coalition.

Watch the video interview here and scroll down to read more.

The new framework will bring the city into compliance with the 2016 Comprehensive Plan ordinance language that says Neighborhood Plans will be “respected… integrated and incorporated” into SA Tomorrow.

And, finally, it makes good on the Comprehensive Plan’s promise - in its first chapter - “not to alter or negate” Neighborhood Plans.

Neighborhoods were at the heart of the 1997 Master Plan, which called on the city to “Strengthen the use of the Neighborhood Planning Process and neighborhood plans,” and “Provide additional technical assistance and incentives to encourage neighborhoods to plan.”

The 55 neighborhood plans here on the city’s website range in length up to 254 pages, and each lists as many as 200 contributors who met for a year or more to create the documents, in collaboration with the city.   

When neighbors learned the Planning Department was intent on scrapping their carefully crafted plans, they felt betrayed and angry, as shown in this video of a Mahncke Park Neighborhood Association Meeting with Senior Planner Garrett Phillips

At the April 19 meeting of the Comprehensive Plan Committee, several residents and District 7 Councilwoman Ana Sandoval implored Treviño andCommittee Chair, District 5 Councilwoman Shirley Gonzales to intervene. (read more here)

“I’m really proud that the neighborhoods stood up, and we’re going to protect that right, because that’s who San Antonio is,” Treviño said in a May 19, 2018 video interview with NOWCastSA. He credited Gonzales and Sandoval for helping correct the course of the Comprehensive Plan.

“We re-established the hard work that we put in over the last few years to make sure neighborhoods have their place in the [Comprehensive] Plan - neighborhood plans specifically,” he said.

“We made sure that the Planning Department is not going to take another step forward without the neighborhoods,” he said. “This is a partnership, this is real collaboration, and we’re happy to see this moving forward the way it should be moving forward: with the neighborhoods, not apart from them.”

Under the new framework, Treviño said, the planning department will work closely with the neighborhoods, and he has enlisted the local American Institute of Architects to help facilitate the some discussions throughout the community.

“This really matters,” said Treviño. “This process matters, and how we get there is as important as what we get.”

According to an email sent to by his office the Tier One Neighborhood Coalition, the planning department also agreed that:

  • Neighborhood Association representatives will be included in the larger planning team for large-area discussions and planning

  • Areas with existing Neighborhood Plans will meet with the planning department staff to review and update their neighborhood plan. 

  • The Neighborhood Plans will be fully included as chapters in the Comprehensive Plan for each Area. (For example, the Midtown Area plan would include chapters for the 5 Points plan, Tobin Hill Plan, Mahncke Park Plan, and others.)

  • The Neighborhood Plan updating process will include discussions with previous planning teams, the current neighborhood association and residents of the neighborhood community.

  • For areas without an existing Neighborhood Plan, a new document will be created using this same process. 

  • For those neighborhoods whose existing plans are not available in digital form, a new digital document will be created, keeping the neighborhood plan and updating where the neighborhood would like updates or revisions

  • There will be one large land use map for the whole Area, (such as Midtown) which will be created through a long public process where fluidity along boundaries can be ensured and discussed with each neighborhood during their subplan discussions

  • The larger Area plan document will also include bigger picture discussions such as infrastructure and transit, which cross many neighborhood boundaries


“At the heart of all this, our responsibility as a city is to the community, and not the other way around,” Treviño said. “We need to maintain that trust, we need to maintain transparency, and we need to be very deliberate and clear about the words we use to talk about how we move forward.

“When the community is wanting to grow the city in a very special and authentic way, we need to pay attention to that. How we do that is very important.”